Research execution readiness
These are execution gates for living protocol supplements. The baseline remains unchanged. Bootstrap may create skeletons with explicit pending fields; it must not present them as completed preregistrations or fabricate results. Research execution still requires bootstrap approval.
Common gate
Before a package's confirmatory runs, commit its prior-art collision record, protocol version and hash, exact question/scope, operational definitions, generators or case fixtures, measures, comparison procedures, resource budget, reproducibility environment, acceptance checks, stopping rules, failure handling and interpretation boundaries. Declare exploratory work separately. Any scientific definition change requires an explicit baseline amendment. Freeze the supplement before observing confirmatory outcomes; later deviations preserve the old version and state whether results were already observed.
RP002A
Specify the predictive query and horizon; E0/E1/E2 generator parameters and sanity checks; episode counts/lengths; independent train/validation/test splits and leakage checks; complete seed schedule; B0–B3 architectures, capacity/resource controls and optimization budgets; raw-history length and recurrent-state size; the selected primary metric (log loss is currently only a candidate); aggregation unit; effect-size threshold; uncertainty method; calibration diagnostics; treatment of failed runs; multiple-comparison rules; and the operational meaning of “not systematically” and B1≈B2. Choose these before confirmatory outcomes, with a rationale or a separately declared pilot. No numerical defaults are adopted by this handoff.
RP003
Define the preservation predicate, tolerance and composition/path semantics; deterministic P0–P3 fixtures; expected positive-control behavior; counterexample verification; and the boundary between enumerated examples and general proofs. Retain the non-metaphysical interpretation lock.
RP004
Specify typed G0–G4 fixtures, ground-truth lineage relations derived from construction, R0–R3 encodings, the exact queries each encoding must answer, scoring/verification and merge semantics. Human intuition remains outside the ground-truth contract.
RP005A
Specify graph/target construction, restriction rules, planner tie-breaking and horizons, viability criterion, V0–V2 fixtures, seeds, coverage denominators, primary/secondary measure calculations and uncertainty/decision procedures. Verify the structural reachability inclusion independently of the simulation benefit question.
DAM X
Require supplied source documents with provenance and a bounded pilot question. Until then, preserve only the template and a documented source dependency; do not reconstruct content from assumptions.
Bootstrap readiness snapshot
All five workstreams remain pending execution readiness. Missing experimental parameters are deliberate open research choices, not validator defaults. Bootstrap completion, protocol readiness and authorization to execute are separate checks.
Current readiness — 2026-10-12
The preceding paragraph preserves the bootstrap snapshot, rather than describing subsequent research. Bootstrap approval is on record. RP002A has since completed its scoped second confirmation and internal disposition under D-0004; its package is CLOSED and the first incomplete attempt remains preserved.
RP003 completed its authorized deterministic audit: all 11,100 paths independently replayed with frozen source/input provenance and output hashes verified. See research/RP003/AUDIT_001_REPORT.md; Test TST-RP003001 has scoped Result R-RP003001 (VALID). The operational protocol and baseline remain unchanged. RP003 is CLOSED under D-0005 after explicit internal package review; see research/RP003/RP003_PACKAGE_REVIEW.md. No broad Claim or Q-0 resolution follows. RP004 completed its authorized finite representation audit under a committed source/input freeze: 864 decoder rows and 60 collision comparisons independently replayed. See research/RP004/RP004_AUDIT_001_REPORT.md. Test TST-RP004001 has scoped Result R-RP004001 (VALID). Preparation documents retain their pre-execution status as historical snapshots. RP004 is CLOSED under D-0006 after explicit internal package review; see research/RP004/RP004_PACKAGE_REVIEW.md. Every decoder/collision outcome and the original audit-stage report remain preserved. Q-0 and Q-4 remain ACTIVE. RP005A completed its single authorized recorded audit under the reviewed sixteen-input source freeze: all 24 planner rows, 12 paired comparisons and 35 source certificates independently replayed. See research/RP005A/RP005A_AUDIT_001_REPORT.md. Test TST-RP005A001 has scoped Result R-RP005A001 (VALID); two positive, four zero and six negative paired outcomes are preserved. Both raw and B=3 structural inclusion pass. All pre-execution inputs and Test registration remain unchanged as historical snapshots. RP005A is CLOSED under D-0007 after explicit internal package review; see research/RP005A/RP005A_PACKAGE_REVIEW.md. The two positive, four zero and six negative outcomes, Result and original audit-stage report remain unchanged. Q-2 remains ACTIVE. DAM X retained its supplied-source gate and unresolved obligation through D-0010. D-0008 subsequently completes the actual late Checkpoint A and scoped forward/backward graph review; see cycles/cycle-01/reviews/CHECKPOINT_A.md and GRAPH_REVIEW_001.md. The missed earlier checkpoint is explicitly recorded in CHECKPOINT_A_TIMING_DEVIATION.md, without backdated approval. The historical graph snapshot has 33 records; D-0008 brought the living graph to 34. D-0009 subsequently completes Synthesis Review 1 and Foundation Review 1; see cycles/cycle-01/reviews/SYNTHESIS_REVIEW_001.md and FOUNDATION_REVIEW_001.md. D-0010 subsequently completes the dated What Changed and What Remains Open records; see cycles/cycle-01/reviews/WHAT_CHANGED.md and WHAT_REMAINS_OPEN.md. D-0011 subsequently accepts a completed secondary-report DAM X pilot and the Transition Record; see legacy/damx/PILOT_001_REVIEW.md and cycles/cycle-01/reviews/TRANSITION_RECORD.md. The user supplied SRC-DAMXREPORT2026 before the final source disposition was released; ten exact report units are decomposed, while primary definitions/evidence and stronger survival judgments remain open. D-0012 subsequently accepts the mandatory close bundle and canonical knowledge snapshot. D-0013 subsequently opens Cycle 02 and accepts the RP006 operational entry design for preparation. The living graph now has 43 records across two Cycle manifests. Existing contracts and all prior research evidence stay unchanged. Cycle 01 is PUBLISHED at 13/13 (100%) after both Site deployments succeeded, with exact receipts in cycles/cycle-01/close/PUBLICATION.json. The completed close commit is retained as snapshot_ref and the immutable cycle-01-close anchor. Cycle 02 is OPEN at 0/9 (0%) with RP006 PLANNED. D-0014 accepts producer/verifier, 24 software controls and the preserved known-domain engineering preflight. Its classifications are already observed and disclosed in research/RP006/RP006_IMPLEMENTATION_REVIEW.md. The concrete source-freeze proposal binds exact input/output receipts. Recorded wrapper, external suspension-aware supervisor, complete execution freeze, Test registration and actual pre-execution checkpoint remain pending. Next: implement and review those execution contracts. The accepted RP006 protocol uses six known RP004 constructions, eight whole-field masks and two inquiry families. Its preserved entry plan grants no execution authorization. The close Decision resolves finite governance commitments, with no new research execution or broad Claim.
Source record
Repository path: RESEARCH_EXECUTION_READINESS.md
SHA-256: cc556675ac9899b8e757567df0823ab1743aba1569f3d93814ba3dba75b6e408
This reading view is generated from the source. The downloaded Markdown preserves the original bytes.