Failure-control follow-up review
Review type: independent AI code review, answer-free and limited to the synthetic Cycle 03 preparation integration control. This is supplemental engineering feedback, not human/external approval, an entry decision, or authorization to execute Cycle 03.
Reviewed implementation: scripts/check-finite-lineage-preparation-integration.py, SHA-256 ffa3e0ebacd5e261293c8f4f7bd84c73a199e1e723dcfad3d439dd41f2689e4f.
Reviewed scope: the reviewer rechecked the previously reported partial-file ENOSPC recovery, errno-specific retry, reserve allocation/directory durability, and post-rename directory-sync failure. No candidate inputs were read and no answer-bearing outputs were created.
Disposition: the cited code findings are resolved for the tested synthetic paths. The fallback removes a stale INCOMPLETE.json.partial before the retry and is limited to errno.ENOSPC; the test injects EACCES and confirms there is no retry. The reserve uses nonzero bytes, fsyncs its contents and parent directory, checks size and allocated blocks where available, and removes itself if its directory sync fails. If a receipt's post-rename directory sync fails, the implementation removes the receipt and syncs the cleanup before propagating the error; the integration test confirms the package ends with INCOMPLETE.json and no conflicting COMPLETE.json.
The reviewer reports that the synthetic integration suite passes. The remaining limitation is environmental: injected errors do not establish recovery under actual data-space or metadata-space exhaustion, persistent directory-sync failures, or host suspension/power loss. The 16 KiB reserve cannot guarantee metadata capacity.
Source record
Repository path: research/preparation/FINITE_LINEAGE_FAILURE_CONTROL_REVIEW_2026-10-16.md
SHA-256: 42889942c14a5868acb1b91b8ebeb5db2eee02155f200543ab52ef69d8435b70
This reading view is generated from the source. The downloaded Markdown preserves the original bytes.